Debt financing can be a powerful tool for charities and social enterprises, but it also comes with legal, governance, and financial challenges. Ahead of their presentation at the Not-for-Profit & Charities Law: Legislation, Governance & Compliance webinar, Darren Fittler and Spiro Papadolias shared their insights on navigating debt, managing compliance risks, and leveraging funding opportunities to drive sustainable impact.
1. To start, can you give us a high-level overview of debt financing and why it’s an important tool for charities and social enterprises?
Debt financing is a financial arrangement in which an organisation, governments and individuals borrow funds from a lender or creditor with a formal agreement documenting the terms of the arrangement, including repayment terms, interest and covenants underpinning the loan. It’s a common tool used in the for-profit space, but its role is equally important in the charity and not-for-profit sectors, where access to capital can sometimes be more limited due to reliance on donations, grants, and other forms of external funding.
For charities and social enterprises, debt financing offers the ability to secure necessary funds to support mission-driven initiatives, often providing the capital needed to scale operations, fund long-term projects or acquire essential assets. This could include infrastructure investments, property purchases, or expanding programs that are central to their objectives. These organisations often face challenges in accessing traditional forms of capital because they may lack a consistent revenue stream or substantial assets that can serve as collateral for certain capital raising. Debt financing bridges this gap, offering an avenue to raise funds and pursue critical goals that would otherwise be unattainable.
One of the main advantages of debt financing is it allows these organisations to access funds without having to dilute ownership or control. Instead, the organisation takes on a financial obligation with a clear repayment structure, allowing them to continue to advance their mission while also securing the necessary resources to achieve long-term goals.
For charities specifically, obtaining capital through equity is not possible because charities are prohibited from distributing profits to members/shareholders (including by way of dividend). As such, a loan may be the only way for some organisations to obtain the capital they want.
However, while debt financing opens up new possibilities, it does come with risks. The primary concern is the obligation to repay the borrowed funds, often with interest, regardless of the organisation’s financial performance. For charities and social enterprises, this means ensuring they can generate enough revenue or funding to meet repayment terms without jeopardising their ability to deliver services or further their charitable purpose.
Given the risks, it is essential for organisations to adopt a strategic approach to debt financing. This includes assessing their capacity to repay loans, planning for future revenue generation, and ensuring debt is used in ways that enhance, rather than strain, their financial sustainability. Debt should be seen as a tool for expansion, not as a quick fix for cashflow challenges. With careful planning and oversight, debt financing can be a valuable tool for charities and social enterprises to grow their impact, strengthen their financial health and pursue their mission more effectively.
2. From a legal perspective, what are the biggest compliance challenges charities face when engaging in debt financing?
When charities engage in debt financing, they face several significant compliance challenges from a legal perspective. Below are the key compliance challenges:
2.1 Alignment with Charitable Purposes
-
Charities must ensure any borrowed funds are used in a manner which directly supports their charitable purposes. This means the debt must be used for projects or activities which align with the charity's purpose and activities.
2.2 Governance and Oversight
- The board of a charity has a duty to ensure any borrowing is in the best interest of the charity. This includes conducting due diligence, assessing the risks and benefits and ensuring the debt financing aligns with the charity's long-term purpose and goals.
- Charities must have clear policies and procedures in place for incurring and managing debt. This includes approval processes, risk management strategies and regular monitoring of debt levels and repayment schedules.
2.3 Transparency and Accountability
- Charities must maintain transparency in their financial dealings, if the organisation primarily relies on external funding from the public and donors. This includes disclosing financial statements annually and providing detailed information about the use of borrowed funds.
- Effective internal controls are essential to track spending and help ensure borrowed funds are managed properly. This includes regular audits, financial reporting and ensuring timely repayment of debt.
2.4 Regulatory Compliance and Reporting
- Charities must comply with all relevant legal obligations related to debt financing, including reporting requirements to regulatory bodies such as the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission. This includes timely submission of financial reports and ensuring all borrowing activities are within the legal framework.
- Charities must do their homework and, just like when procuring other goods and services, must ensure the terms of the finance are on arm’s length terms or terms more favourable to the charity.
2.5 Risk Management
- Charities must assess their financial stability and ability to service debt before taking on any borrowing. This includes evaluating cashflow, revenue streams, and potential risks that could impact their ability to repay the debt.
- Developing contingency plans for unforeseen circumstances which may affect the charity's ability to meet its debt obligations is important. This includes having strategies in place for managing financial shortfalls and ensuring the continuity of charitable activities.
3. Are there any misconceptions charities or social enterprises have about taking on debt, and what advice would you give to boards considering this path?
3.1 Misconceptions About Debt in Charities and Social Enterprises
- A common misconception among charities and social enterprises is taking on debt is inherently harmful and should be avoided. This view often stems from a fear of financial instability. However, when managed responsibly, debt financing can be an important tool for growth and can help organisations achieve long-term goals which would otherwise be impossible with limited resources. It provides the opportunity to make strategic investments, such as building infrastructure or scaling up programs, which ultimately enhances the organisation’s impact and sustainability.
- Another misconception is taking on debt will alienate donors who may fear the organisation is financially unstable. In reality, donors are generally more concerned with the effectiveness and transparency of an organisation’s operations rather than its use of debt. When debt is taken on for a clear and impactful purpose, and when the organisation communicates how it will support the mission, donors are likely to understand and support this approach. In fact, properly managed debt can demonstrate the organisation’s commitment to strategic growth, which can bolster donor confidence and support.
3.2 Advice for Boards Considering Debt Financing
- Before taking on debt, boards must ensure they fully understand the financial obligations involved, including the terms of repayment, interest rates and the risks associated with borrowing. It is essential to assess the organisation’s current financial position and its ability to meet these obligations without jeopardising ongoing operations. Debt should be viewed as a tool for growth rather than a quick fix for cashflow issues. A realistic repayment plan should be in place.
- It is vital for boards to integrate debt management into a comprehensive, long-term financial strategy. Debt should not be viewed in isolation but as part of a balanced approach which includes other revenue streams such as donations, grants, and earned income. By carefully planning how debt fits into the broader financial picture, organisations can ensure borrowing doesn't undermine their core mission or sustainability. Proper management of debt, alongside other funding sources, enables the organisation to remain financially resilient while pursuing ambitious goals.
By addressing these misconceptions and following sound financial practices, boards can help ensure debt financing becomes a powerful tool for advancing their organisation’s mission and creating lasting impact.
4. Looking ahead, how do you see the role of debt evolving in the charity and social impact space, and what trends should organisations be preparing for?
4.1 Predicted trends
Looking ahead, the role of debt in the charity and social impact sector is expected to evolve in several key ways, driven by emerging trends and changing financial landscapes. These developments will offer new opportunities and challenges for charities and social enterprises seeking to leverage debt as a tool for growth and sustainability.
- One significant shift is the growing use of social loan facilities, which are loans specifically tied to achieving social outcomes rather than solely financial performance. These types of loans are becoming increasingly popular because they align well with the missions of charities and social enterprises, whose primary focus is often social impact rather than profit maximisation. Social loan facilities allow organisations to secure debt financing with terms that reflect their social goals, enabling them to pursue initiatives which directly contribute to their mission. As impact measurement frameworks continue to improve, social loan facilities could become a central feature of the sector, providing charities with more access to capital linked to specific, measurable outcomes.
- Another evolving trend is the rise of blended finance models, which combine grants, donations, and debt to fund large-scale, mission-driven projects. These models allow charities and social enterprises to access capital from diverse sources. Blended finance increases the flexibility and sustainability of funding options by balancing the philanthropic nature of grants with the repayment obligations of debt. This approach enables organisations to tackle more ambitious initiatives, such as infrastructure development, program scaling, or capacity building, while maintaining financial stability. As blended finance gains traction, charities will need to be adept at managing complex funding structures to optimise the value of each funding source.
- The growing field of impact investing, where investors seek both financial returns and social impact, is reshaping how charities access capital. Impact investors are increasingly interested in supporting organisations which can demonstrate measurable social outcomes alongside financial sustainability. This shift presents an opportunity for charities and social enterprises to tap into debt financing from impact investors who are willing to provide capital with flexible terms, in exchange for a focus on creating tangible social change. Charities which measure and report their social impact effectively will likely be better positioned to attract debt funding from this growing pool of investors.
- As the landscape of social finance evolves, regulatory frameworks surrounding debt financing are also likely to change. Charities and social enterprises need to stay informed about shifts in regulations that could affect their ability to access debt or alter their compliance requirements. For example, changes in tax laws, reporting standards, or lending criteria could impact the terms of debt agreements, eligibility for certain types of financing, or the overall cost of borrowing. Being proactive in understanding and adapting to regulatory changes will be essential for organisations to maintain financial health, compliance, and access to capital.
4.2 Preparing for the Future
To navigate these trends and maximise the potential of debt financing, charities and social enterprises should take the following steps:
- Organisations should explore the growing opportunities within social loan facilities, blended finance and impact investing. Understanding these tools and integrating them into their financial strategies will provide more avenues for raising capital while staying aligned with their mission.
- As impact investing becomes more prominent, it will be important for organisations to develop robust systems for measuring, reporting, and demonstrating their social outcomes. This will not only enhance the appeal of their financing proposals but also help build trust with donors, investors, and stakeholders.
- Charities must stay informed of any changes in financial regulations that could affect their borrowing options. This includes understanding new compliance requirements, tax incentives and regulatory shifts in the social finance space, ensuring that they remain competitive and compliant in an evolving environment.
By preparing for these trends and adopting a strategic approach to debt management, charities and social enterprises can effectively leverage debt financing as a tool to achieve their long-term goals and create lasting impact.
Disclaimer: The statements, analyses, opinions and conclusions in Legalwise Insights are those of the respective authors and not of Legalwise Seminars Pty Ltd which acts only in the capacity as editorial co- ordinator of the content in Legalwise Insights. No part of any article can be regarded as legal or financial advice. Although all care has been taken in the preparation of all articles, readers must not alter their position or refrain from doing so in reliance on any information contained therein. Neither the respective authors nor Legalwise Seminars Pty Ltd accept or undertake any duty of care relating to any part of Legalwise Insights
Liability limited by a scheme approved under the Professional Standards Legislation
